[Readmelater]

BehanVox: In Bihar, It’s Raining Cash Schemes For Women

This week in BehanVox: Japan's first woman prime minister, Ladki Bahin Yojana scam, and more

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter that brings you top stories, gender news from the world, and our team’s reading recommendations.

Hello and welcome to BehanVox! Bihar elections are here, so can cash schemes for women be far? They aren’t raining down, they are pouring. And a look at gender news from across the world.

Story So Far

Four days ago, with the election heat growing in Bihar, RJD’s Tejashwi Yadav promised the state’s Jeevika Didis – community mobilisers for self help groups under a livelihood scheme – the moon if the INDIA bloc is voted to power. Permanent government jobs, a monthly salary of Rs 30,000 and even interest free loans for the 1.45-crore strong force. “This is my commitment. What I promise, I deliver,” he declared, per a report in The Times of India.

The NDA, which has been doing its bit to impress Bihar’s women voters with cash schemes, instantly dismissed the scheme as untenable citing budget figures. This, even as the Nitish government promised to increase the honorarium of ASHA workers from Rs 1000 to Rs 3000.

Come election time, as BehanBox has been reporting consistently (herehere and here), it is becoming increasingly common for political parties to promise women voters cash transfers in exchange for support. And what better catchment than millions of women stuck in underpaid, overworked ‘volunteer’ jobs as sevikas and didis. As to how these promises are fulfilled, we have enough examples to not be too optimistic.

It was a similar election promise made two years ago to another group of community workers in Chhattisgarh by the BJP that appears to be going south, as we reported this week. Ahead of the 2023 state elections, the ruling BJP had declared in its manifesto that it would press for Mitanins – the earliest cadre of community health-workers – to be fully incorporated into the National Health Mission (MHM) and that their incentive would be hiked by 50%. There was here the promise of government employment and all that it holds.

Last August, when the NHM announced that it would take over the operations of the Mitanin programme from a state-civil society partnership organisation, the workers believed that it would pave the way for a smooth transition. But the euphoria was short-lived. Soon after, the programme faltered: Workers told BehanBox that payments have become erratic and there is little clarity about how the new system will work. And within months of the transition, the government roped in an NGO to run the programme, creating fresh apprehensions in the cadre.

“Earlier, we used to get all our dues on time but since the NHM has taken over, the payment system has been a mess,” said Lamiya Yadav, a Mitanin from Kawardha’s Pandariya block. In the first few months, the NHM used to send messages providing details about the remuneration, she said, but these stopped after three months. “Now we get random amounts and that too sporadically,” she said.

Two months ago, thousands of Mitanins and trainers marched to the capital city of Raipur pushing that the promises made by the party in its manifesto be fulfilled. What went wrong with the promised shift in operations?

Read our explainer here.

Talking Point

Good News, Bad News: In a world led by strongmen we now have an iron lady as well: Sanae Takaichi, a conservative politician and a protege of former PM Shinzo Abe, has become Japan’s first woman prime minister. A fan of the British prime minister Margaret Thatcher – she has advocated for tougher immigration restrictions and hawkish policies on China. Though she has a cool image as a heavy metal enthusiast, her social views are patently conservative – she is a pro-natalist and believes that women should not be allowed to keep their maiden name once they marry. This, NPR points out, is ironic for she still uses her maiden name in professional and public life.

Ladki Scam: According to an investigative report by Indian Express, the Maharashtra government has found that among the beneficiaries of the Ladki Bahin Yojana were at least 12,431 men. Declared in the run-up to the state elections when the ruling regime’s fate seemed uncertain, the scheme gives Rs 1,500 every month to women aged 21-65 from families earning less than Rs 2.5 lakh annually. As many as 77,980 ineligible women too have drawn from the scheme. There are other structural flaws to the scheme as well (here and here).

Caste Factor: Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M K Stalin announced this week in the assembly a panel for legal and policy measures to prevent ‘honour’ killings. This comes in the wake of the murder this July of Kavin Selva Ganesh, a Dalit, in a case related to caste pride. The panel is to be headed by retired Madras High Court judge K N Basha but will also include legal experts, progressive thinkers, and anthropologists.

Cricket Win: India’s women cricketers have bagged themselves a historic place in the ICC Women’s World Cup 2025 semifinals after a 53-run win over New Zealand in Navi Mumbai. The win was spurred by centuries from Smriti Mandhana and Pratika Rawal. Incidentally, the digital viewership of the women’s world cup has grown five fold since 2022, advertisers are lining up and analysts have declared that women players are no longer in the shadows of bro cricket.

BehanVox Recommends

  • Exactly what fuels the digital manosphere boom? The promise of community, wealth and a cool lifestyle, says this interactive explainer from the Guardian.

  • The concept of izzat (honour) has been twisted in South Asian families, argues this essay in The Wire. ‘While men own honour, women are made to become it,’ says the writer.

Want to explore more newsletters? In Postcards, we send you missives on the places, people and ideas that brought Team BehanBox joy. Our monthly offering Postscript invites you, the reader, into our newsroom to understand how the stories you read came to be – from ideation to execution. Subscribe for more.

Support BehanBox

We believe everyone deserves equal access to accurate news. Support from our readers enables us to keep our journalism open and free for everyone, all over the world.

Donate Now